William Winter edited a collection of O'Brien's works, to which he appended tributes by George Arnold and Frank Wood.
Arnold's tribute to O'Brien appears in William Winter's edited collection of O'Brien's life and professional accomplishments.
Arnold refutes charges the O'Brien's short story "The Diamond Lens" was plagiarized from North's manuscripts.
Arnold writes a tribute to O'Brien's "Personal Characteristics."
Arnold mentions the loss of Wilkins along with O'Brien.
Though many details about his early life are in dispute, scholars agree that Arnold was born in New York City and tha
Characterized as an "eccentric literary man not without a spice of genius," William North was born in England and eventually settled in New York City (W. Rossetti 48-49).
